“Good Passions”

Standard

I came across this taxonomy of the εὐπάθεια.  Stoics often have to refute the emotionless stereotype of the little-S stoic, and especially of the Sage.  Some modern writers have noted the three core healthy or innocent emotions, but they can be broken down a little further.

After speaking with some other Stoics, it’s worth noting that the feelings we’re discussing here aren’t virtues, they’re the result of good judgments, the natural feelings of the behavior of one living according to nature, i.e. as a rational and social critter.

It’s worth noting, that some modern writers on Stoicism have discussed the εὐπάθεια as well, and you’ll notice a difference in translation for some of them*.  I’ve used LSJ, Middle, and Strong’s dictionaries, as well as discussions with experts in all periods of Greek language.

 

* I would be remiss if I didn’t thank Jean Efpraxiadis for correcting my translations, and working with me through a seemingly never ending slew of questions.  Thank you, Yannos!

So let’s look at the fruits of our work.

  • εὐπάθεια (eupatheia) – Good passions, healthy emotions, innocent emotions.
    • βούλησις (boulesis) – Wishing, aspiration, looking forward to doing well.
      • εὔνοια (eunoia) – Goodwill, being reasonably well disposed towards people situations
      • εὐμένεια (eumenia) – Goodwill, having feelings of kindness and solidarity with people.
      • ἀσπασμός (aspasmos) – Having feelings corresponding to acceptance, kind welcoming and embracing people and situations.
      • ἀγάπησις (agapesis) – Affection.
    • χαρά (chara) – Joy.
      • τέρψις (terpsis) – Delight.
      • εὐφροσύνη (eufrosune) – Mirth.
      • εὐθυμία (euthumia) – Cheerfulness.
    • εὐλάβεια (eulabeia) – Reverence, piety, caution.
      • αἰδώς (aidos) – Shamefast, modesty, moral self-respect.
      • ἁγνεία (hagneia) – Purity, chastity.

So, in contradiction to the “emotionless Stoic,”  the practicing Stoic progressing towards virtue has many healthy emotions/feelings awaiting her on the way.  When looking at the variety and depth of the good feelings which are in accordance with nature, it’s surprising how prevalent the ‘stiff upper lip’ stereotype actually is.

ἀπάθεια, then, isn’t to be cold and without affect, but to have properly used impressions and judgment which results in healthy feelings.  This brings the Sage down into the realm of real-world possibility.  Rather than trying to overcome human nature and eliminate all emotions a la Spock, we have a concept of a fully human being, living in accordance with nature feeling and experiencing what humans rightly ought to do.

Image result for diogenes lampWhen the Sage is viewed in this light, she’s a more comforting role model to my way of thinking.  Not a superman, but a *real* one.  Precisely the one Diogenes goes to look for with his lamp.  Sometimes that passage gets translated as real man, sometimes as honest man, but either way.

It’s important to note how the concept of the Sage changed during the lifetime of the Stoa, as it morphed from an achievable ideal to theoretic ideal with a pit stop at the virtue of the every-man.

The idea of an achievable virtue, however, is much more motivating to me.  Maybe the already virtuous can strive for something unachievable, but many of us down here in the streets find that a tough pill to swallow.

So be sure to cast aside the idea of the unfeeling Stoic, we have a whole taxonomy chart to prove otherwise.

One thought on ““Good Passions”

  1. Thank you for exploring this territory, which is often overlooked. Being a technologist, I always look for the techne 😉 how do you turn a pathos into a eupathei? What do you actually do or prepare to turn hedone into chara? Phobos into eulabia? epithumia into boulesis? It would be great if we had a treatise like “On Anger” instructing us in morphing the pro-pathei energy of a “bad” emotion into a “good” one.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s