I had the opportunity to be a guest on a new Stoic podcast, and it has recently been released. Per, the author and host, submitted it to r/Stoicism, so I will link you to it to read about it in his own voice.
Longtime readers will remember that I’ve written about Socratic Meditation in the past. I recently came across this paper, and am in the process of reading it. I can’t speak to its conclusions or methods (as I haven’t read them yet) but I thought I would share it with you in case you’re also interested in this avenue of exploration.
Here’s the paper: “Socratic Meditation And Emotional Self-Regulation: A Model For Human Dignity In The Technological Age,” Journal of Interdisciplinary Studies 24 (2013): 1-29. (with Paul Carron). This link may require registration to download, but should be readable without logging in.
I would like to devote more time in the coming weeks to developing a meditation practice. While I wrote about it previously, I haven’t done much of it of this sort. I’ve been reading a bit about different meditation types, and this hint about Socrates’ practice keeps nagging at me, and really merits some further investigation.
If any readers of the blog have a formal meditation practice, I’m interested in your findings experiences, and thoughts in this regard. Please let me know in the comments or privately as you choose.
* * *
After reading the paper, this isn’t too much here as far as non-technical information that I didn’t cover in my first description. It was nice to see some of my conclusions and inferences supported. I don’t have the technical background to speak to the section on research and brain states, but it was interesting.
My overall conclusions remain the same: that this is a practice which merits further exploration.
If you are interested in a pre-order, the Cora Lutz translation of Musonius Rufus’ Lectures and Sayings is going to be back in print for the first time in a long time. This edition will be bilingual, with Koine Greek and English.
For US-folks, it should be available in mid-February, and my understanding is that it will be available in April in Europe and elsewhere.
Unfortunately, there is no cover art available yet.
If you are interested, you can use this link, and I may get a small commission. I’ve already pre-ordered it, as I’ve wanted a physical, bilingual version for some time. The US version is $22, which seems like a deal to me. When I was searching for print versions of 1947 translations, the cost was significantly higher.
Here’s the link:
I wanted to drop a quick link to a blog I thought you might find of interest. It’s a system (new to me) for organizing what one reads. Enjoy.
“There is pain in the foot, and a tingling sensation in the joints; but we still hide the complaint and announce that we have sprained a joint, or else are tired from over-exercise. Then the ailment, uncertain at first, must be given a name; and when it begins to swell the ankles also, and has made both our feet “right” feet, we are bound to confess that we have the gout.”
— Seneca, Moral Letters 53
Today a bit of Stoic remedy helped me. It was nice to find that after an absence, when I reached out philosophy was still there. I’ve been dealing with hyperuricemia (commonly called gout) for the past four years. It’s a kidney problem in which those organs are unable to adequately filter the blood, leading to high levels of uric acid. This form crystals which lodge in the joints, cutting into the tissues there and causing swelling. As the tissues swell, they cut more and more, recursively. Eventually, the swelling becomes so severe that the affected joint begins to dislocate.
About 60% of this problem is genetic, the remainder from lifestyle choices. Foods high in purines metabolize creating uric acid, so dietary control is a key factor. Triggers are highly idiosyncratic.
Gout is the most painful thing I’ve ever experienced. It recalibrated my “1-10” scale. It is difficult to describe, or relay the pain. In a bad flare-up, there is no comfortable position, even the weight of a bedsheet is unbearable. The pain is so intense, I cannot read or watch TV. I can only experience the pain. It shuts everything else out.
When I first got diagnosed, I undertook some experiments to find the triggers. Common ones include meat, red meat, shell fish, lentils, cauliflower, alcohol. I ate a vegetarian diet for two months, then introduced meat excepting red for two months. I abstained from cruciferous vegetables for two months. I avoided alcohol for two months.
After about half a year, I determined that hops (like in India Pale Ales) were problematic, as was high fructose corn syrup.
Avoiding these two things has helped, but not entirely reduced the attacks. Soemtimes I’ll months without a flare-up, other times I’ll have three in two weeks.
During a flare-up, I cannot usually walk. The joints of the feet, my ankles, and occasionally knee are affected.
So, why a discussion about a medical issue? I’m having a flare-up today, and while I was waiting for a ride home to get emergency meds, a miscommunication occured and I thought briefly I was going to be left behind.
A creeping sense of panic began to set in, and I found a sliver of space to recognize this anxiety as an impression, and not the thing itself.
I remember the words of Epictetus:
“Lameness is a hindrance to the leg, but not to your ability to choose. Say this to yourself with regard to everything that happens, then you will see such obstacles as hindrances to something else, but not to yourself.”
— Enchiridion 9.
I repeated them several times, and wiggled into that mental distance between the impression of anxiety, and the reality of the situation.
I was borrowing trouble from the future, but what I needed to do was exercise my normal will in the here and now.
So I stood a moment in the stairwell, looked at the pain, and felt calm. I had the tools to handle this situation.
I reached out, and found philosophy there to lend her hand.
Seneca mentioned gout, as well as another other classical philosophers. So it’s an interesting situation that we, separated by so much time and space, often find ourselves handling many of the same issues.
This is the first in a series of polls of the blog. I’m interested in ‘what Stoicism means to you.’ Please aim for a 70% compatibility, if one of these is “pretty close” to your view, please don’t use the OTHER option.
You may review the results from this, and other polls here.
You can now submit questions via #CuriousCat , if you are so inclined.
Please check out https://curiouscat.me/MountainStoicWV